Back to Blog

Criminalizing Racialized Bodies: Then and Now

This blog post was written by NCTE member Rachel Endo. Endo is the author of The Incarceration of Japanese Americans in the 1940s: Literature for the High School Classroom, the newest publication in NCTE’s High School LIterature Series. 

In my new book The Incarceration of Japanese Americans in the 1940s: Literature for the High School Classroom, I describe how English teachers could use Japanese American literature around the topic of the World War II incarceration as a springboard to connect secondary students to current events and other issues that matter to today’s youth.

The border crisis in the United States isn’t a new phenomenon. Since its founding, our nation has excluded different ethnic and racial groups from citizenship, and has mistreated many more racialized Americans who were also born and raised here.

But an outpouring of bipartisan outrage occurred in June 2018 when journalists reported that thousands of Central Americans were being detained in metal cages, held behind chain-linked fences, and living in detention centers in desolate areas throughout the US.

“Detained migrants allege they were forced to drink foul-smelling water and [sic] spoiled food” (CNN July 18, 2018  https://www.cnn.com/2018/07/18/us/trump-administration-migrant-detention-conditions/index.html); detainees also described getting sick, going hungry, or both due to the squalid living conditions.

More recently, more troubling accounts have emerged that migrant children are being drugged against their will, and in some cases, physically and sexual abused by detention workers. The Washington Post’s editorial board released a strongly worded statement: “Migrant children were stripped, drugged, locked away. So much for compassion” (August 5, 2018).

Many Americans have made comparisons to what has been happening to Central American migrants with the mass incarceration of Japanese Americans during World War II. Former First Lady Laura Bush wrote a moving op-ed for The Washington Post (June 17, 2018) that in part read: “These images are eerily reminiscent of the internment camps for U.S. citizens and noncitizens of Japanese descent during World War II, now considered to have been one of the most shameful episodes in U.S. history.”

A day after Bush’s post, actor George Takei published an op-ed in Foreign Policy (June 18, 2018) that drew parallels between his family’s experiences as incarcerated Japanese Americans in the 1940s and the treatment of Central American migrant families, but highlighted one troubling difference: “At least during the internment of Japanese-Americans, I and other children were not stripped from our parents.”

Here, I’ll offer additional ideas about classroom connections specific to the current border crisis, focusing particularly  on the mistreatment of migrant children and the separation of families.

 

Suggested Pre-Readings

The current border and migration crisis didn’t just occur suddenly. It’s symptomatic of a longstanding legacy whereby the US government has, time and time again, encouraged or sanctioned racial profiling and segregation. I suggest two short pre-readings before assigning writing activities or engaging students in discussion:

  1. Theta Pavis’s article from The Huffington Post, “Decades of U.S. intervention in Central America echo in present border crisis” (July 22, 2018), provides brief context regarding how the US’s geopolitical involvement in Central America over the past several decades has facilitated many of the sociopolitical conditions leading to millions of people being displaced from their homes and motherlands. Also, learning how the US has profited from the violence and wars in Central America and throughout the world provides students with a more complete picture of the conditions leading to the current border crisis.
  2. Stanley Thangaraj’s blog “Our Family Values, and What We Truly Value” (July 18, 2018) provides a strong sociohistorical analysis of how families of color and indigenous families in North America have long been subjected to cruel and illegal acts of physical and symbolic violence.

 

Connections to the Classroom

In times of national anxiety, teachers have a challenging yet critical opportunity to engage students in rich discussions about the state of our democracy in uncertain times.

As a word of caution, conversations about immigration, one’s legal status, and racialization in relation to current events may be sensitive and traumatizing for many students. Young people who are from immigrant and refugee backgrounds, or whose families’ legal status is under question, may feel extreme anxiety about their safety and security.

However, criminalizing racialized bodies also isn’t a new phenomenon, as there are many examples, past and recent including over the last two generations, about how different racialized Americans have been subjected to mass deportation and incarceration. Arguably, the main difference now is how the proliferation of online and social media has increased the speed by which most Americans are able to access headline news.

 

Assignment Ideas

Below are possible assignment ideas that could easily be adapted to fit a teacher’s specific learning goals for a particular unit.

Teachers who want their students to write more extensive formal essays could assign lengthier assignments that also have connections to a specific set of standards and/or texts.

 

Example 1: Create a short mashup (no longer than five minutes) overviewing a major issue or theme related to the deportation, detention, or legal status of immigrant, migrant, or refugee families in the US. You might follow or investigate the fate of one specific family; look at how ICE raids (or fears of them) are impacting our community or other communities; or provide a comparative analysis of a specific news story that connects to another social issue that you care about. In your mashup:

  1. Briefly summarize the basic facts- who, what, when, and where.
  2. Try to provide various perspectives about why this happened by drawing on factors such as current attitudes, laws, and policies. Your mashup should contain at least three distinct examples.
  3. Find art, books, images, poems, songs, and/or sound clips that speak to this family’s, community’s, group’s, or person’s concerns, experiences, and/or identities.
  4. Prepare to share your mashup in 5 minutes.
  5. Mashups for Educators is a freely available source that provides tips on how to create mashups along with various tools that teachers can share with their students: http://mashupsforeducation.weebly.com/mashup-tools.html

 

Example 2: Analyze how the treatment of Central American refugees who have been recently detained and/or deported is different and/or similar to the incarceration of Japanese Americans in the 1940s. To structure your essay, select a theme below, or propose your own:

  1. Experiencing trauma (and/or being retraumatized) while in detainment
  2. How government-sanctioned racial profiling leads to the mass detainment of an ethnic or racial group
  3. Images of racially segregated concentration camps
  4. Impacts of detainment- on both the familial structure and intergenerational relations (especially between children and their parents)
  5. Media representations of children in the camps
  6. Politics of racialized immigration laws, specifically exploring how and why White immigrants, both past and present, have been largely been immune from racist acts of exclusion
  7. Social construction of “American” citizenship- who is or isn’t considered “American”
  8. Xenophobic rhetoric — then and now

 

Example 3: Compare and contrast the current border crisis to other racialized and xenophobic moments in US history including hate crimes, laws, or policies that have discriminated against, excluded, or targeted a specific social group. Possible examples to investigate:

  1. 1882: Chinese Exclusion Act
  2. 1924: Immigration Act
  3. 1930s: Mexican/Mexican American Repatriation
  4. 1942: Executive Order 9066, which led to the mass incarceration of Japanese Americans
  5. 1943: Zoot Suit Riots
  6. 1987: New Jersey Dotbusters
  7. 2001: Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act (also known as the USA Patriot Act)
  8. 2017: Executive Order 13769 (also known as the Muslim Travel Ban)
  9. 2017-present: Recent ICE raids leading to the detainment and deportation of ethnic groups such as Cambodian American refugees and other racialized groups including other Latinx communities who aren’t recent Central American refugees
Final Thoughts

In his recent Foreign Policy op-ed, actor-activist George Takei provides a powerful reminder why the current border crisis should concern all Americans: “I cannot for a moment imagine what my childhood would have been like had I been thrown into a camp without my parents. That this is happening today fills me with both rage and grief: rage toward a failed political leadership who appear to have lost even their most basic humanity, and a profound grief for the families affected.”

 

 

 

 

 

Rachel Endo is Founding Dean of the School of Education at the University of Washington, Tacoma. Order her book at the NCTE store.